I initially ordered a set of TKC 8 shot moonclips through Amazon and was disappointed because they did not fit my revolver so I returned them. I then noticed these are very specific by gunmake and even ammo, so I went in the TKC website and ordered 8 shot for N frame (the first ones did not state this), selecting one option for standard and one for Hornady ammo. Both fit my gun perfectly so I am now a believer in TKC. Both sets of mooclips fit my gun. The standard fits all ammo I have but not the Hornady ammo. The Hornady clips take the ammo no hitch. So yes, these are awesome and as long as you order to proper fit you will be satisfied with the quality and how useful these clips are. I also own the moonclip loader and spent cartridge take down tools by TKC and like I said I'm a believer in their fit and quality. Top notch product.
